7 Ways to Increase Employee Retention: Pay

benefits as an hr retention strategy

In our employee retention series, we’ve talked about flexibility, employee growth, and diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI). Now, let’s look at another topic that has a massive impact on attracting and retaining top talent: pay!

The Great Resignation and the impacts of an ongoing pandemic have long-lasting effects. As a result, employees are evaluating their personal and work lives and listing their non-negotiables. You’ll find that things like culture, work-life balance, and flexibility are increasingly important. But compensation remains a pivotal factor in choosing whether employees stay at a current job or look for new opportunities with better pay.

“Other outside factors may be at play as well,” said Lindsey Nichols, Nextep’s Vice President of Human Resources. “At Nextep, we’ve seen other companies, often located in high cost-of-living areas, attempt to recruit employees by offering higher salaries than we typically see in our lower cost-of-living location. As a result, this shift has prompted us to fine-tune our compensation strategy as an organization.”

A Pew Research Center study from February 2022 found that 63% of workers who quit a job in 2021 said low pay was why they left. Significantly, an average of 3.98 million workers quit their jobs each month in 2021, and similar trends continue into 2022. Now is therefore the time to take a serious look at your company’s compensation as a key part of your employee retention strategy.

A compensation review is a great retention tool to keep in your company’s tool belt. Let’s take a look at some general tips on how to go about using a compensation review to review employee pay at your company.

Who’s in charge?

Firstly, take the time to establish who will take charge of your company’s compensation review. Depending on the size of your company and how many employees you have, an individual could manage the project. Alternatively, you can put together a committee to handle it. Departments involved with company-wide compensation reviews are typically human resources, business operations, and finance.

Take the pulse of your company

Go right to the source! Ideally, you’re talking to departing employees about their reason(s) for leaving. If compensation factored into their departure, be bold and ask them what their new pay and job title will be. Use this information in conjunction with other data to help you make compensation decisions.

Also, conducting an anonymous employee survey may be part of your regular process. Include a question about employees’ satisfaction with pay. What are they telling you? Use that data to your advantage!

Gather market data

It takes a lot more than gut feelings to set competitive salaries at your company. Getting access to accurate and verified salary data from trusted sources will be critical in your compensation research. It’s crucial to understand precisely where your company falls in terms of pay – businesses conducting salary assessments typically pay labor research firms for access to verified salary information.

For example, Nextep uses Payscale to help us compare our salaries based on job title, experience, and location to ensure we’re offering pay that’s competitive in the current job market.

Since the market changes often, it’s essential to do these assessments regularly, at least annually. We have found that COVID, inflation, current market conditions, The Great Resignation, and the rapidly changing way people work have caused a big shift in salary data and expectations in the past year, for example.

Once you’ve obtained reliable salary data, your next big task is to spend time analyzing the data you’ve gathered. Compare your company’s pay against the verified salary data to identify gaps in employee compensation and use that information to develop salary ranges and benchmarks for each role within your organization.

Put the research into action

Now you have up-to-date salary ranges for your company, it’s time to put the research to good use! Firstly, compare your employees’ current pay against the new salary ranges you’ve created. Then, determine if anyone is underpaid or where you can increase compensation to be more competitive.

From here, you can work on matching employee salaries to market trends. Compare the two to ensure you’re offering the most competitive pay possible for your organization. This step will help you retain employees and stand out to potential candidates in the current job market.

Communicate

To sum up, being compensated fairly and competitively at work can go a long way to make your people feel valued and appreciated! Be transparent with your people. Let your employees know your company is working to monitor trends in the current job market and actively taking steps to ensure pay is as competitive as possible.

Attracting and retaining top talent is something we pride ourselves on at Nextep. We’d love to chat with you about how we can help your business conduct a compensation review! Our goal is to help you bring in the best and brightest talent and keep them around in today’s changing market.

Let’s talk so your company can join The Great Retention!

 

Want to learn more? Check out our other blogs in The Great Retention series!

DEI

Flexibility

Growth

Engagement

Benefits

 

Also on Nextep

Sept. 30, 2026. Norman, OK — Nextep, a leading professional employer organization (PEO), has been selected for the 2026 Fortune Best Workplaces in Consulting & Professional Services™ List by Great Place to Work® and Fortune magazine. This is Nextep’s 7th consecutive year on this prestigious list. The Best Workplaces in Consulting & Professional Services™ award […]
Read more
Mark your calendars! New compliance rules take effect this October, and protecting your business starts with knowing what is changing. The latest updates bring major changes to state and federal employment laws, changing everything from workplace policies to payroll. Key changes include the federal repeal of OFCCP affirmative action mandates and Alabama’s ban on sexual […]
Read more
NORMAN, Okla. (September 15, 2026) — The University of Oklahoma Athletics and Learfield’s Sooner Sports Properties announced today a new, multi-year partnership with OU and Nextep that will see the Oklahoma-based company’s branding featured on-court at Lloyd Noble Center.  Nextep’s logo will be prominently displayed on the playing surface at Lloyd Noble Center during all […]
Read more
July brings a fresh wave of state and federal compliance updates. Nextep has the complete rundown to keep your business on track. Get started using these quick links: Part 1: Federal Compliance Spotlight: New EEOC National Enforcement Plan On June 4, 2026, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) voted to replace its previous Strategic Enforcement […]
Read more
NORMAN, Okla. – March 26, 2026 – Nextep, a nationally recognized leader in the Professional Employer Organization (PEO) space, is thrilled to announce its latest strategic expansion into four new U.S. markets: Scottsdale, Arizona, Atlanta, Georgia, Chicago, Illinois, and Greenville, South Carolina. These moves represent a significant step in the company’s growth strategy as it continues to […]
Read more
NORMAN, Okla. – February 3, 2026 – Nextep, a leading HR services firm, announced today that they have won the Best of HR Services® Award for the second consecutive year for providing superior service to their clients. ClearlyRated’s Best of HR Services® Award winners have proven to be industry leaders in service quality based entirely […]
Read more
If your employee needs health-related time off, the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) may require your company to provide it. This FMLA 101 guide will help you navigate the process. Now that we’ve covered the basics, this guide will explain the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) to help you handle employees’ leave requests […]
Read more
For years, HR teams have asked: If an employee has a 30-minute appointment, but it takes them an hour to get there, is that drive time Family Medical Leave Act (FMLA)-protected? The Department of Labor (DOL) just gave us a definitive answer in Opinion Letter FMLA2026-2. For employers, this is both a compliance requirement and […]
Read more
The One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA) introduced a number of changes for employers. Luckily, Nextep is here to help! As our clients’ PEO and Employer of Record, Nextep automates much of the compliance, tax reporting, and administrative burden created by the OBBBA. While the laws change, our partnership ensures your business stays compliant. Here […]
Read more
Many new or revised state law updates will go into effect in the coming months. Our Compliance experts have summarized regulations in your state that may impact your business. Follow the quick links below to find your state: FEDERAL UPDATE Paid Family and Medical Leave Effective January 1, 2026, the tax credit for employers that […]
Read more
The Department of Labor (DOL) Wage and Hour Division’s Opinion Letter, FMLA2025-02-A, provides clarification on how employers must calculate an employee’s total available FMLA leave hours. These rules speak especially for those with non-traditional schedules that include mandatory overtime. What It Means for Employers The core takeaway is that employers must calculate an employee’s FMLA […]
Read more
A recent Florida court ruling in McDaniels v. State struck down the state’s open-carry ban, effectively making open carry the new law for adults who can lawfully possess a firearm. This ruling follows Florida’s existing “constitutional carry” law (effective July 1, 2023), which allows for permitless concealed carry. Here is a summary of the key […]
Read more

Download the Elevate by Nextep™ App


Download the Nextep Mobile App in Apple iOS or Google Play