Do You Ban the Box? Here’s Why You Should.

Beth Dean 01.17.23

Asking about criminal history is risky business. Here’s what to do instead.

You may be breaking the law if your job application includes a checkbox asking the candidate if they’ve ever been convicted of a crime. Banning this question during the application process, sometimes referred to as “ban the box,” gives people with criminal histories a better chance of fair assessments of their skills and qualifications instead of being denied employment from the beginning.

Sometimes, a criminal history may not affect the job at hand. Denying employment from the start across the board to anyone with a criminal record often leads to disparate impact among those in protected classes. Additionally, basing hiring off the simple checkbox on the application doesn’t consider the nature of the person’s crime, rehabilitation, or how long ago it happened.

Therefore, these laws aim to combat disparate impact and give qualified candidates a fair chance at employment.

Ban the Box States

So far, 15 states and several more localities have enacted “ban the box” laws among private employers, forbidding them from asking candidates about their criminal history on a job application. The list includes:

  • California
  • Colorado
  • Connecticut
  • Hawaii
  • Illinois
  • Maine
  • Maryland
  • Massachusetts
  • Minnesota
  • New Jersey
  • New Mexico
  • Oregon
  • Rhode Island
  • Vermont, and
  • Washington.

Additionally, 35 states and many localities have enacted this ban in the public sector. 

What To Do Instead

So we’ve established that asking about criminal history on a job application is risky, but does this mean you’re required to hire criminals?

Absolutely not. Here’s what to do instead.

Instead of asking about criminal history in the beginning phases of a job application, we recommend reserving that question until after you have extended a conditional offer of employment, contingent on background screening results. 

This way, if a candidate is eliminated from consideration for a job before reaching this phase, you can rest assured it isn’t because of criminal history. You’ll only be extending those conditional offers of employment to candidates who seem like they would be a good fit for your company, so you’ll know at that point if their skills and qualifications match your needs.

When running a background check, only screen for criminal history that would directly impact the job. For example, if someone has a DUI but won’t be doing any driving for your company, that shouldn’t be a factor in employment.

Likewise, you’ll want to look at the time since the criminal incident. There may be a chance that the person has been rehabilitated from their past actions.

This process should be a transparent discussion between you and the candidate to assess the nature of any criminal history found and how it would impact the job. You may find it best to part ways or that the record would not affect the position.

For case-by-case advice on how to handle hiring and background screen results, contact your HR business partner at Nextep. Our certified experts are here to help!

 

Nextep Weekly Tip Signup

Also on Nextep

Ah, the holiday season—a time for joy, festivities, and the age-old puzzle of compensating your employees. Let’s demystify the rules of holiday pay for both our hourly (nonexempt) and salaried (exempt) workers. For the Hourly Heroes Picture your business decked out in holiday cheer, but your nonexempt employees are sipping cocoa at home. Under the […]
Read more
Keep Your Party Pants Professional As the year ends, and you’ve achieved feats at work that deserve a standing ovation, the holiday office party is your well-earned, much-awaited reward.  But beware! When the festive spirit meets the allure of a bottomless drink supply, things can take a wild turn, leaving you nursing a hangover, regret, […]
Read more
We’ve talked recently about the importance of sustainability in business. Let’s take it a step further and look at ESG, or Environmental, Social, and Governance.  The Impact of ESG on Companies Environmental (E) Companies that focus on their environmental impact are making a positive change. They reduce their carbon footprint, use clean energy, and find […]
Read more
Sustainable business isn’t just for hippies! As we discussed in our previous article, sustainability is increasingly important to today’s business. It is a crucial and relevant issue that affects everyone and every organization, regardless of industry or beliefs. Sustainability involves taking a long-term, holistic view of how we interact with the environment and our communities, […]
Read more
At Nextep, we aim to stay informed about CEO concerns in order to better help with problem-solving. We were surprised to learn that sustainability has become a top concern. The statistics bring CEO concerns to light: A Gartner survey found that CEO concern about sustainability has increased 292% from their 2021-22 survey. In a survey […]
Read more
It’s not the most savory of topics, but still merits discussion. All of your employees will need to use the bathroom during work. Here’s a potty primer, if you will. Disability and Bathrooms The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) has clear regulations on bathroom accessibility in the workplace. Much of the guidance revolves around making […]
Read more
We’ve reported at length about preventing discrimination in the workplace. But let’s take a step back now and brush up on Title VII, the sweeping regulation that started it all.  Title VII of the Civil Rights Act forbids discrimination in any aspect of employment, including hiring, firing, pay, job assignments, promotions, layoff, training, fringe benefits, […]
Read more
Time to check your handbook again for NLRB compliance The National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) has been busy shaping employee handbooks and workplace policies. With the recent Stericycle Inc. decision, the NLRB has introduced a new legal standard for evaluating employer work rules under Section 8(a)(1) of the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA).  Understanding the […]
Read more
The Answer Depends on Your State…For Now As we reported in January, non-compete agreements preventing employees from working for competitors are becoming increasingly unenforceable. The FTC is currently working on banning them at a federal level, but unless and until that decision comes, non-competes are enforced at a state (and sometimes even local) level.  As […]
Read more
When hiring workers, knowing whether they’re employees or independent contractors is essential. The difference between the two can significantly impact your business, including your tax liability, your liability for workers’ compensation claims, the worker’s rights and benefits, and your ability to control how your workers do their jobs. Read all about it here, and check […]
Read more
Employers Must Now Prove “Substantial Increased Cost” to Deny Religious Accommodation Recently, the Supreme Court ruled that employers must now demonstrate a substantially increased cost to deny an employee’s request for a religious accommodation.  This ruling, which comes in the case of Groff v. DeJoy, clarifies the standard for “undue hardship” under Title VII of […]
Read more
Here’s How the Recent Ruling Affects Your Company You may have read that in late June, the Supreme Court struck down affirmative action in college admissions. Here’s the implication this ruling could mean for you as a small or medium-sized business owner. To be clear, the Supreme Court’s decision on affirmative action does not explicitly […]
Read more

Download Our App