Is Your Worker An Employee or Independent Contractor?

Nextep Weekly Tip - employee handbook

A frequent and important issue employers commonly deal with is whether to classify a worker as an employee or an independent contractor. 

Put simply, the difference between an employee and an independent contractor lies in who controls the work.


An employee works according to the company’s rules and schedule. The employee’s pay is subject to taxes, and they can be eligible for company benefits such as insurance or paid time off. Pay is reported on a W-2.

Independent Contractor 

An independent contractor is hired for specific work on a job-to-job basis, often (but not always) under contractual agreement. The worker must have a TIN (Taxpayer Identification Number). Taxes are the contractor’s responsibility; none are taken from the pay. Contractors furnish their own tools, work on their own schedules, and decide how the job will get done. Pay is reported on 1099.

Employers can ask themselves some basic questions to aid in the determination between employee and independent contractor:

  • Do you control how the work is done, including hours, location, or rate of pay? 
  • Do you offer benefits to anyone in a similar position? 
  • Do you furnish the worker with a workspace, computer, or other needed tools? 
  • Is this person in your company’s managerial, executive, or key role? 
  • Are others with similar duties at the company classified as employees?

If the answer to these questions is yes, then the worker is likely an employee, not an independent contractor. 

Misclassifying employees

Companies that misclassify employees as independent contractors cause workers to miss out on several federally-mandated protections including: 

  • Minimum hourly wage
  • Overtime compensation 
  • Workers’ compensation 
  • Unemployment benefits
  • FICA tax withholding
  • Benefits

Employers may be held liable for these missed benefits if they are found to have misclassified employees and other company offerings the worker may have missed, such as paid time off and health benefits. 

Further, the misclassification of employees is a hot topic for the Department of Labor (DOL), which partners with the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) in these efforts. The DOL and IRS have a longstanding Memorandum of Understanding, in which they share information between agencies and work together to target and eradicate employee misclassification. 

Nextep often assists worksite employers in auditing specific jobs to determine if they should be classified as contractors or employees. We have usually found that the person is an employee and helped our client achieve compliance. 

If you need help classifying your workers correctly, Nextep has solutions for you. Contact us to see how we can keep you and your business complaint.

Nextep Weekly Tip Signup

Also on Nextep

How do you handle employee promotions? When promoting one of your star employees to a management or supervisory position, companies should take the time to train and help the manager adjust to their new role.  An employee’s relationship with their immediate supervisor is one of the top five factors in job satisfaction, so a new […]
Read more
It should be no surprise that your employees post on social media or even blog throughout the day ─ maybe even on company time or equipment. And while they may not post on the clock, it’s unlikely that after hours they think their social media or blog posts could have consequences at work. While employers […]
Read more
The holidays can raise confusing questions on how to pay your employees, especially since there are separate rules for nonexempt and exempt employees. Here is a quick reminder on how to pay both groups during holidays. Pay for Nonexempt Employees If your business is closed for the holiday(s), the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) does […]
Read more
The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) recently released the “Know Your Rights” poster, which updates and replaces the previous “EEO is the Law” poster. Covered employers are required by federal law to prominently display the poster in their workplace.  DOWNLOAD POSTER What it covers The poster includes federal laws prohibiting job discrimination, as well as […]
Read more
Did you know that claims for unemployment benefits from former employees can increase your State Unemployment Tax Act (SUTA) tax rate? Managing the unemployment process can sometimes take excessive resources making it difficult for business owners to give unemployment claims the attention they require. Nextep manages this process for our PEO clients and can help […]
Read more
How to handle the SSN in the workplace The Social Security Administration has announced that an individual may now self-select their gender on their social security number (SSN) record. Previously, the sex marker would have to match medical records and other legal documentation. Now, a person can select the male or female sex designation of […]
Read more
Workplace violence among employees is a threat that all companies should be aware of and work to prevent. In 2020, workplace assaults resulted in 20,050 injuries and 392 fatalities, according to Injury Facts®. Background screening before hiring can help find warning signs and prevent employers from hiring a known threat. Sometimes, though, the employee has […]
Read more
When completing the I-9 to verify employment eligibility, you may notice that the form will expire on October 31, 2022. Usually, the government releases a new form to replace the old one. However, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) and US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) has announced an extension to the existing form.  As […]
Read more
Should an employee clock out for a short break? What if they leave the office? Knowing the ins and outs of employee pay can be tricky, so today we’re tackling break times to help keep you in the know.  Generally, nonexempt employees do not clock out when taking short breaks of 20 minutes or less […]
Read more
Can I make my employee remove his nose piercing? Can I require dresses? What if my employee smells horrible?  These and other questions frequently arise when companies are developing effective dress codes. A thorough dress code that respects each employee’s judgment and comfort can be challenging for employers to come up with on the fly […]
Read more
Get the low down on how to handle pay correctly. Should you pay your employees for working during lunch? Yes.  Easy answer! Right? Well, no. Though the simple answer is an emphatic yes, it’s a bit more nuanced.  The topic of lunch and compensable time can be tricky. There are many ways an employee could […]
Read more
An employee’s first day at a new job can set the tone for the working relationship going forward. In fact, according to research by Brandon Hall Group, organizations with a strong onboarding process can improve new hire retention by 82% and productivity by more than 70%. Though the employee may feel stressed or nervous, the […]
Read more

Download Our App