Managing Misconduct? Keep This in Mind.

Beth Dean 08.16.19
88 Working Sunflair Dude

How do you handle a not so great employee?

The workforce is filled with capable, professional adults with good intentions, working together to enrich the company, each other, and their families…and then, there are some bad apples.

Unfortunately, a rotten employee will sometimes find their way into a company. Maybe this person spreads malicious gossip. Maybe this person only feels fulfilled at the expense of others. Maybe this person is a thief. This person is certainly not the norm, but their presence can become so overwhelming that it infects the whole company.

So how do you manage blatant misconduct? There are many ways, including solid recruitment and screening processes that don’t let the rotten employee through the door in the first place. Assuming we don’t have perfect future-predicting capabilities, sometimes they slip through. 

Here’s one important thing to keep in mind when managing misconduct: Don’t terminate too fast…or too slowly.

Some managers are ready to call it quits the moment an employee deviates from the norm. There’s no reason to terminate a potentially great employee if things can be worked out. To terminate an employee for misconduct, the act usually must be egregious to win an unemployment claim or avoid a wrongful termination or discrimination claim. 

There are some situations in particular where managers should be careful not to mistake for misconduct, including: 

  • Excessive time off for medical problems or work comp injury treatment
  • Job performance issues that can be fixed through better training and expectations
  • Legitimate complaints about company or manager practices, employee pay, or safety
  • Nonconformity due to religion, gender, or other differences protected by Title VII

On the other side, managers are sometimes too slow to action. They hold on to the optimistic and admirable hope that the mess can be fixed. Others may be afraid to confront the issue head-on and want to passive-aggressively let the person go in a “layoff.” Sometimes, it’s time to let go, and it’s important to record the reasons accurately. 

Sometimes, the situation demands immediate action for the safety of others. Some situations in which an employee may need to be immediately terminated include: 

  • Violent threats or acts
  • Proven theft (be sure to include legal authorities)
  • Severely unprofessional or malicious misconduct
  • Sexual harassment

One item to note: Many states have at-will employment, meaning there is no formal contract and the employment relationship can end at any time for any reason. While at-will employment does add a layer of protection to both parties, we must stress that you should use it carefully and sparingly.

We think of an at-will termination as a quick route to the courtroom since there are so many laws that protect employees , making it difficult for the company to prove that one of those protected reasons wasn’t the real reason for termination.

Above all, use your Nextep HR business partners. They’re professionally certified experts who have seen some of the worst cases of misconduct and can walk you through your own issues, step by step. 

If you’re facing a rotten employee or are in need of human resource guidance, please contact Nextep’s HR team.

Also on Nextep

Get the low down on how to handle pay correctly. Should you pay your employees for working during lunch? Yes.  Easy answer! Right? Well, no. Though the simple answer is an emphatic yes, it’s a bit more nuanced.  The topic of lunch and compensable time can be tricky. There are many ways an employee could […]
Read more
An employee’s first day at a new job can set the tone for the working relationship going forward. In fact, according to research by Brandon Hall Group, organizations with a strong onboarding process can improve new hire retention by 82% and productivity by more than 70%. Though the employee may feel stressed or nervous, the […]
Read more
Your company policies and values are only as good as the leaders implementing them. Get your leadership team on board, make sure they’re living out your company values, and support them to ensure they get the help they need to lead well. “Half of workers who quit their jobs say they left because of their […]
Read more
…And what you should ask instead Say you’re recruiting top talent for your company and find a few excellent candidates. When it’s time for the job interview, you smile, shake hands (or wave hello over Zoom), and sit down for a productive conversation. Your first question is a softball to help warm them up: “Have […]
Read more
How often do you get the chance to expand beyond your current retention or recruiting strategies? It’s common for managers to get stuck in the daily work routine and overlook the growth opportunities their employees want. That neglect may mean a greater chance of talented employees leaving in the short run. Around 48% of employees […]
Read more
Could your employee handbook stand up to a lawsuit or EEOC claim? Here are six tricky areas that could mean trouble for your company. Landmine 1: A handbook that’s older than dirt When was the last time you reviewed your company’s employee handbook? If it’s been longer than a year, then it’s been too long.  […]
Read more
We all know the importance of regular physicals and check-ups, but when was the last time you checked in on your mental health? May is Mental Health Awareness month, serving as a good reminder of how crucial a healthy mind is in the overall map of our wellbeing. This list and infographic can get you […]
Read more
If you’ve made it to this blog on leadership training, chances are you’ve spent some time with us the last couple of months as we dove into turning The Great Resignation into The Great Retention.  So far, we’ve covered flexibility, DEI, employee growth, pay, employee engagement, and benefits. While each of these is important, when […]
Read more
It’s no surprise benefits are one of the top reasons for employees staying with a company or going elsewhere. The Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM) study shows that 36% of employees leave for better benefits. Employee retention can be daunting, but we’re here to break it down! Therefore, we’re talking today about benefits. We’ll look […]
Read more
Employee engagement is a crucial piece of the recruiting and retaining top talent puzzle. When it comes to employee engagement, few people in Nextep can speak more authoritatively on the subject than our very own Director of Happiness, Tracey Hixon. To help you get started, Tracey answers some questions about how to retain employees by […]
Read more
In our employee retention series, we’ve talked about flexibility, employee growth, and diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI). Now, let’s look at another topic that has a massive impact on attracting and retaining top talent: pay! The Great Resignation and the impacts of an ongoing pandemic have long-lasting effects. As a result, employees are evaluating their […]
Read more
Now is the time for employers to carefully review any arbitration or employment agreements they have in place. On March 3, 2022, President Biden signed the Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act (HR 4445).  In cases of sexual assault or harassment in the workplace, many employers ask employees to sign arbitration […]
Read more

Download Our App