Religious Accommodations, the Supreme Court, and Your Company

Beth Dean 09.12.23
Weekly Tip Blog Header - 2023-09-12 Religious Accommodations

Employers Must Now Prove “Substantial Increased Cost” to Deny Religious Accommodation

Recently, the Supreme Court ruled that employers must now demonstrate a substantially increased cost to deny an employee’s request for a religious accommodation. 

This ruling, which comes in the case of Groff v. DeJoy, clarifies the standard for “undue hardship” under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, which prohibits discrimination in employment based on religion, race, color, sex, and national origin.

Previously, the standard for undue hardship was whether the accommodation would impose more than a minimal cost on the employer. This meant employers could deny religious accommodations even if they were inexpensive or easy to implement. The Groff decision changes this, requiring employers to show that the accommodation would impose a significant financial or operational burden on their business.

So, what does this ruling mean for employers? Here are a few things to keep in mind:

  • Be careful when denying religious accommodations. You must show that the accommodation would impose a significant financial or operational burden on your business.
  • Be more creative in accommodating religious employees. Consider alternative scheduling arrangements, job reassignments, or other accommodations that would not burden your business significantly.
  • Be more transparent in your decision-making process regarding religious accommodations. Document your reasons for denying an accommodation and be able to explain how the accommodation would have imposed a significant burden on your business.

Employers should take this opportunity to review their policies and procedures to ensure that they are in compliance with the new standard. 

Here are some additional tips for employers:

  • Be proactive.
    Don’t wait for an employee to request a religious accommodation before considering how you will handle requests. Think through your company’s stance and create an unbiased handbook policy. Then, take each request on a case-by-case basis with the help of an HR pro or attorney. 
  • Be flexible.
    Be willing to work with your employees to find a solution that meets their religious needs and does not impose a significant burden on your business. There are often creative ways to accommodate religious employees that do not require a lot of time or expense.
  • Document everything.
    If you deny a religious accommodation, document your reasons for doing so and be able to show a significant burden or cost this would cause your business. This documentation will help you if the employee later challenges your decision.

The Groff decision is a significant development in the law of religious accommodations. For help applying this to your employees, please get in touch with an attorney and your HR Business Partner at Nextep.

Also on Nextep

Spoiler Alert: Yes We frequently see a question posed to HR pros: “Do I have to pay my employee if…?” We’ll go ahead and give you a major hint at the outset. In many of the scenarios we see, the answer is yes, you do have to pay your employee. Here are a few scenarios. […]
Read more
The Answer Depends on Your State…For Now As we reported in January, non-compete agreements preventing employees from working for competitors are becoming increasingly unenforceable. The FTC is currently working on banning them at a federal level, but unless and until that decision comes, non-competes are enforced at a state (and sometimes even local) level.  As […]
Read more
When hiring workers, knowing whether they’re employees or independent contractors is essential. The difference between the two can significantly impact your business, including your tax liability, your liability for workers’ compensation claims, the worker’s rights and benefits, and your ability to control how your workers do their jobs. Read all about it here, and check […]
Read more
Here’s How the Recent Ruling Affects Your Company You may have read that in late June, the Supreme Court struck down affirmative action in college admissions. Here’s the implication this ruling could mean for you as a small or medium-sized business owner. To be clear, the Supreme Court’s decision on affirmative action does not explicitly […]
Read more
The new Form I-9 is here, and it has some changes that you need to know about. The latest version of Form I-9, Employment Eligibility Verification, took effect on August 1, 2023. Employers should take note this new form has a few changes. Here’s a quick rundown. Employers must use the new form for all […]
Read more
NLRA Protections: They’re Not Just for Unions In the intricate fabric of company dynamics, employee protections exist, even in non-unionized companies, as granted by the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA). These protections give employees the freedom to engage in open discussions on various workplace matters, even those conversations that may make employers a tad uneasy. […]
Read more
Your Cheat Sheet to Poster Penalties We all know the importance of labor posters, but did you know how much noncompliance could cost you? Let’s take a closer look at what this means for employers. Each poster has its own associated fine if not displayed. The DOL and EEOC have set fine levels that include: […]
Read more
Navigating I-9 Compliance Though the COVID-19 pandemic has officially ended, we’re still seeing changes to compliance in the aftermath. Today, we bring you important information about form I-9.  The U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) and U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) recently made an announcement about form I-9. The flexibility to check identity and […]
Read more
Have you ever felt stuck in a job that doesn’t fully utilize your skills or expertise? Or have you ever been a part of a team that just doesn’t seem to have the right skills to do the job effectively? This is a common problem in the workplace, known as the skills gap. But don’t […]
Read more
Are you ready for the new regulations impacting your state? In July and August, several states will implement noteworthy updates to their employment laws, bringing changes and protections for workers. These updates address various aspects of the employment relationship, including wages, benefits, discrimination, and harassment. One area of focus has been minimum wage adjustments. Many […]
Read more
Start planning for your future superstar. What would happen to your company if you lose a key leader or employee tomorrow? It’s a tough question, but necessary. You want to ensure your company can continue, even without the lifeblood that keeps it running smoothly today. That’s where succession planning comes in. Succession planning is identifying […]
Read more
Let’s talk about something that can make a huge difference in our work lives – Emotional Intelligence (EI).  Emotional Intelligence is like a superpower that helps us navigate our own emotions and understand the emotions of others. It’s all about self-awareness and empathy, which leads to better communication, stronger relationships, and improved decision-making. It’s like […]
Read more

Download Our App