Should You Pay Your Employees for Working During Lunch?

Beth Dean 09.27.22
Weekly Tip - working during lunch

Get the low down on how to handle pay correctly.

Should you pay your employees for working during lunch?


Easy answer! Right?

Well, no. Though the simple answer is an emphatic yes, it’s a bit more nuanced. 

The topic of lunch and compensable time can be tricky. There are many ways an employee could “accidentally” work during lunch without being paid, throwing your company out of compliance with the Department of Labor (DOL).

Lunch breaks, or the lack thereof, are scrutinized heavily by the DOL since they’re a potential source of missed pay for nonexempt employees. Many companies have an employee handbook policy that mandates lunch breaks, but sometimes that policy is ignored during busy times.

Here are 5 areas to watch out for to ensure you’re paying your employees correctly regarding lunch breaks.


Working during lunch – 5 areas for extra caution:

  1. Automatic meal deductions

Some companies will automatically deduct an hour from an employee’s timecard daily, assuming they will take lunch. The trouble is, sometimes employees get busy and have their lunches cut short or even cut altogether. The meal deduction should reflect the actual time taken off. 

  1. Meals at the desk

The temptation is too great to work when you’re eating at your desk. Even if you’re chowing down on a sandwich and perusing the latest online sales, if an email or work message pops up and you read or respond to it, you’re suddenly working again. Think of meals at the desk as continued work…with food.

  1. Offsite business lunches

Sometimes hourly-paid employees will clock out for a business lunch for which they should be paid, such as meeting with a client, attending an industry luncheon, or relocating a department meeting to a restaurant. Work done off property is still work. 

  1. Shop talk

Sometimes, an employee will eat in the company break room, and a manager or coworker will come in and ask questions about the status of a project or even ask the employee to take a client or vendor phone call. For a meal break to be a bona fide unpaid break, according to the Department of Labor, it must be at least 30 continuous minutes. A work-related interruption that cuts into this time turns it into a compensable short break.

  1. Forgetting to clock back in

Sometimes employees forget to clock back in after lunch. Even if the employee did not keep proper records, they still must be paid for the time worked. As a manager, if you see a suspiciously long lunch break, it would also be a good idea to reach out to the employee to ensure any working time doesn’t go unpaid.


What are you to do about the employee who flaunts the mandatory lunchtime policy and regularly continues working? 

First, make sure you do have a policy that’s being violated. If it’s not in writing and isn’t enforced equally to everyone, it’s not a policy. Reach out to your HR pro to make an update, then roll out the changes and get signed acknowledgments from all employees.

Second, check if this employee is exempt or nonexempt from overtime pay. If the person is exempt, you may still want to enforce your lunchbreak policy to help maintain their health and fairness among all employees.  But speaking from a compliance point of view, it‘s the nonexempt employees you’ll want to keep an especially close eye on to make sure they receive compensation for all hours worked, even if they’re supposed to be off the clock.

Third, do continue to pay them for hours worked. Employers cannot deduct unauthorized hours worked; they must be paid for that time if they worked. 

If the employee works unauthorized hours during lunch, it’s a discipline problem; not a payroll problem. Connect with your HR pro to get advisement on beginning the progressive discipline process.

Need help on more employee matters? Subscribe to our weekly tips! We’ll keep you in the know!

Nextep Weekly Tip Signup

Also on Nextep

Year-End Tax Prep As we begin to wrap up 2022, we want you prepared for tax season and a smooth transition into the new year. That’s why we’ve compiled the tax prep key details in one place.  W-2s You and your employees can opt-in to receive W-2s securely and electronically instead of receiving a mailed […]
Read more
We’re coming to that time of year when you need to know about paying year-end bonuses. With Nextep, we’ve got you covered. Here are the details: Timeline for bonuses All requests for 2022 bonuses should be made by Friday, December 23. Requests made after December 23 must be paid in the 2023 tax year.  Requests […]
Read more
How do you handle employee promotions? When promoting one of your star employees to a management or supervisory position, companies should take the time to train and help the manager adjust to their new role.  An employee’s relationship with their immediate supervisor is one of the top five factors in job satisfaction, so a new […]
Read more
It should be no surprise that your employees post on social media or even blog throughout the day ─ maybe even on company time or equipment. And while they may not post on the clock, it’s unlikely that after hours they think their social media or blog posts could have consequences at work. While employers […]
Read more
The Ins and Outs of a PEO Relationship Are you thinking of moving your in-house HR tasks to a PEO? That’s great! Here’s what to expect. Professional Employer Organizations (PEOs) are a tried and true way for companies like yours to take advantage of some powerful perks: Access better benefits than you might be able […]
Read more
The holidays can raise confusing questions on how to pay your employees, especially since there are separate rules for nonexempt and exempt employees. Here is a quick reminder on how to pay both groups during holidays. Pay for Nonexempt Employees If your business is closed for the holiday(s), the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) does […]
Read more
The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) recently released the “Know Your Rights” poster, which updates and replaces the previous “EEO is the Law” poster. Covered employers are required by federal law to prominently display the poster in their workplace.  DOWNLOAD POSTER What it covers The poster includes federal laws prohibiting job discrimination, as well as […]
Read more
Did you know that claims for unemployment benefits from former employees can increase your State Unemployment Tax Act (SUTA) tax rate? Managing the unemployment process can sometimes take excessive resources making it difficult for business owners to give unemployment claims the attention they require. Nextep manages this process for our PEO clients and can help […]
Read more
How to handle the SSN in the workplace The Social Security Administration has announced that an individual may now self-select their gender on their social security number (SSN) record. Previously, the sex marker would have to match medical records and other legal documentation. Now, a person can select the male or female sex designation of […]
Read more
Workplace violence among employees is a threat that all companies should be aware of and work to prevent. In 2020, workplace assaults resulted in 20,050 injuries and 392 fatalities, according to Injury Facts®. Background screening before hiring can help find warning signs and prevent employers from hiring a known threat. Sometimes, though, the employee has […]
Read more
When completing the I-9 to verify employment eligibility, you may notice that the form will expire on October 31, 2022. Usually, the government releases a new form to replace the old one. However, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) and US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) has announced an extension to the existing form.  As […]
Read more
Should an employee clock out for a short break? What if they leave the office? Knowing the ins and outs of employee pay can be tricky, so today we’re tackling break times to help keep you in the know.  Generally, nonexempt employees do not clock out when taking short breaks of 20 minutes or less […]
Read more

Download Our App