Traditional vs. Roth 401(k): Select the Right Retirement Savings Plan for You

Man Computer Desk Decision

Do you think taxes will be higher or lower by the time you’re ready to retire? 

Without a time machine, none of us know how the tax system will shift during our years before retirement. We do, however, have choices on how we handle our taxes today. 

Taxes are important to consider when deciding whether a traditional 401(k) or Roth 401(k) is right for you. Nextep’s 401(k) gives you the ability to choose. Here’s a rundown.

Traditional 401(k): Pay Taxes Later

Let’s say your annual income is $35,000, and you contribute $3,000 into a traditional 401(k). Your 401(k) contributions are deducted from your paycheck before any taxes are taken out. When you file your taxes, you have reduced your taxable income from $35,000 to $32,000. 

Reducing your taxable income allows you to pay less in taxes during your working years. However, if you don’t pay taxes on your 401(k) contributions when you put them into your account, the IRS will require you to pay taxes as you take them out.* Withdrawals in retirement will be taxed like working income, whether those dollars are what you contributed or are investment earnings. 

Traditional 401(k) Pros

Traditional 401(k) Cons

  • Pay less in taxes during your working years
  • Pay taxes on the earnings of your contributions
  • Pay taxes at an unknown, future tax rate
Roth 401(k): Pay Taxes Now

A Roth 401(k) works differently. Let’s take the same $35,000 annual income and contribute $3,000 into a Roth 401(k). This contribution will be deducted from your paycheck after your taxes are paid. When you file your taxes, your taxable income will still be reported as $35,000. 

There aren’t tax savings during your working years for contributions into a Roth 401(k). The benefit of a Roth is enjoyed in retirement. Because taxes are paid on Roth contributions upfront, you will be able to take qualified distributions in retirement tax-free*— including investment earnings. 

Roth 401(k) Pros

Roth 401(k) Cons

  • Withdraw money in retirement tax-free
  • Any earnings on your contributions are tax-free
  • Pay taxes at a known, current rate
  • Pay higher taxes during your working years

Since none of us know what the future holds, you might consider splitting your savings between traditional and Roth contributions. Essentially, you would have two buckets of money within your 401(k) account that would give you the freedom to choose how to withdraw money in the most tax-efficient way. Just like investors diversify their investment strategies, you can diversify your tax strategies.

Keep in mind, if your employer offers a company match, employer match dollars in your account will always be traditional, and their pre-tax contributions will be taxed at retirement. 

Check out this Roth vs. Traditional calculator to compare the plans and choose which one may be right for you. 

Your Nextep 401(k) team is here to help! Our 401(k) has a financial advisor who can help you look at all the factors to consider when deciding if a traditional 401(k) or a Roth 401(k) is right for you. 

We would love to partner with you in creating a retirement savings plan! Reach out to us at

*Early withdrawal penalties and income taxes may apply if you withdraw from a 401(k).

Also on Nextep

How to handle insurance during leave of absence Employee leaves of absence from work raise questions, especially about health benefits. Who shoulders the insurance premiums during the leave? Let’s untangle this knot one thread at a time. Paid Leave: Business as Usual Paid leaves are straightforward. Simply maintain regular benefit deductions from their paychecks as […]
Read more
Running a business is exciting, but let’s face it, it comes with its fair share of risks.  That’s why Nextep is thrilled to partner with CoverWallet, bringing you exclusive access to comprehensive commercial insurance designed to keep your company safe and sound. Aon’s enhanced platform is powered by CoverWallet, a digital broker designed to make […]
Read more
Taking Charge of Our Well-Being Amidst the hustle and bustle, it’s easy to overlook one of our most valuable assets—our health. Let’s take a moment to reflect on the importance of preventive healthcare because prevention truly is the best medicine for our well-being. What exactly is preventive healthcare? Well, it’s all about staying ahead of […]
Read more
Need help deciding on benefits? Just call your Health Advocate! Have you ever had a question about your benefits? Honestly, who hasn’t? Nextep Health Advocate program can help. Health Advocate is the nation’s leading healthcare advocacy and assistance company. Their experts help employees and their family members navigate the healthcare system, resolve healthcare and insurance […]
Read more
Empowering Employees to Take Control of Healthcare Expenses Healthcare costs can be a real burden on your wallet, affecting your finances and overall well-being. But don’t worry! With planning and proactive steps, you can take control and save money on your healthcare expenses.  Know Your Health Insurance: First, make sure you understand your health insurance […]
Read more
Did you know that mental health assistance is among the most sought-after employee benefits? (Source: Forbes) Nextep’s Aetna health plans are committed to providing comprehensive coverage for your mental and behavioral health needs. Let’s explore how we can support your healthier mind and body journey using your health benefits. Your mental health is a crucial […]
Read more
Exploring the Benefits of a Health Reimbursement Arrangement (HRA) You may have heard about a health reimbursement arrangement (HRA) as a money-saving option for your benefits, but what exactly is it? Is it right for your company? Let’s break it down. An HRA is a benefit plan where you, as the employer, cover a set […]
Read more
Republished with permission from Health Advocate Pride month is celebrated in June in honor of the 1969 Stonewall uprising in New York City. During that event, the LGBTQIA+ community protested for the right to socialize without harassment.  Today, Pride celebrations continue globally as jubilant expressions of how far the LGBTQIA+ community has come. The events […]
Read more
On January 30, 2023, the federal government announced that the two national emergencies addressing COVID-19, the public health emergency (PHE) and the national emergency, will end on May 11, 2023.  Starting May 12, 2023, health plans and group plan sponsors will no longer be subject to federal requirements for coverage of COVID-19 testing, vaccinations, and […]
Read more
Is your pet insured? How about your identity? We all know the value of the major benefits, such as health, dental, vision, life, telehealth, and disability. But what about some of the lesser-known benefits? You and your employees may be missing out on some significant advantages. Pet Insurance Protect your pets with pet insurance options. […]
Read more
Federally-Approved Qualifying Events You may have heard the term “federally-approved qualifying event” when making changes to your health benefits outside the open enrollment window. Here’s a quick rundown of what that means. Any tax-free employee benefits fall under Section 125 of the IRS code. Because the IRS regulates these benefits, employees are only permitted to […]
Read more
8 Easy Ways to Save Money on Health Care Costs Admittedly, there are many things out of your control when it comes to healthcare costs. But, there are still steps you can take that add up to more dollars in your pocket. Following these tips can help save money on health care costs. Use preventive […]
Read more

Download Our App

Download the Nextep Mobile App in Apple iOS or Google Play